Sloane

This article is a stub. You can help Destinypedia by expanding it.

Sloane
Biographical information
Homeworld:	Earth
Species:	Human
Gender:	Female
Hair color:	Black (Greying)
Eye color:	Brown
Political and military information
Affiliation:	Vanguard Stoneborn Order Firebreak Order
Rank:	Deputy Commander Vanguard Scout
Class:	Titan
Notable info:	Investigated the Fallen withdrawal from the Cosmodrome. Fought in the Red War

"The war's over, and we've lost."

— Sloane

Deputy Commander Sloane was a female Titan Guardian of the Last City who served as a Vanguard Scout. During the Red War, Sloane served as Commander Zavala's deputy and secured the moon of Titan as an outpost for the Vanguard.

Biography

Early Life and Career

"The siege is broken. The stalemate we’ve had with the Eliksni for what, a hundred years? It’s over. We won."

— Sloane, in a report to Commander Zavala

At some point after being resurrected by her Ghost, Sloane arrived at the refugee camp below the Traveler. Alongside her fellow Guardians, including Lord Shaxx, Sloane helped construct massive walls to protect the growing settlement, which eventually became known as The Last City. She was present when the Guardians first encountered and fought the Hive on Earth, after which she gained a hatred of them and became determined to wipe them out. Sloane also fought in the Battle of Twilight Gap and helped fight back the Fallen's attempted assault on the Last City.

Sloane aiding the construction of the City Wall.

Over the years, Sloane rose through the ranks of the Vanguard to become Deputy Commander of the Vanguard under Commander Zavala. During the Age of Triumph, she received reports that the Fallen Houses were abandoning their strongholds and disappearing in the aftermath of the SIVA Crisis. In response, Sloane oversaw a scouting mission to the Cosmodrome in Old Russia to confirm the reports. They found that most of the House of Devils and Kings had indeed abandoned not only the region, but their House banners as well. Marcus Ren informed Sloane that he believed the Fallen's siege of the Last City had finally been broken. Sloane reported this information to Zavala, and informed him that she was coordinating with The Reef, Iron Lords, and the Warlocks to uncover more intelligence on the Fallen's new motives and movements.

The Red War

Retreat to Titan

Sloane alongside Commander Zavala.

"We have a counter-offensive to plan. To do that, we need to get this station up and running. There's a fleet to prep, Guardians to arm, and a trove of intercepted Red Legion transmissions to decrypt. It's critical we gain access to the station's Control Center."

— Sloane, briefing the Young Wolf

When the Red Legion invaded the solar system and conquered the Last City, imprisoning the Traveler in a cage to strip the Guardians of their Light, Sloane evacuated Earth with hundreds of other Guardians and refugees under the leadership of Commander Zavala. Sloane reported to Zavala aboard one of their ships in order to begin planning their resistance to the Cabal invasion. While leaving Earth, the fleet intercepted a encoded Cabal transmission, but were unable to decrypt it. They settled upon Titan, one of the moons of Saturn, as their rally point. Sloane and Shipwright Amanda Holliday aided Zavala in crafting a message to send to the scattered Guardian forces throughout the system. She found the Commander's messages to be void of hope and made it sound like the war was already lost, but found herself unable to criticize Zavala beyond asking him to be more inspiring, although Amanda had no such issues and raised their concerns to him. Sloane backed up Amanda, pointing out that they were not using most of their fuel to reach Titan to simply hide and that Zavala's message needed to include a plan for the Guardians to rally behind. Zavala did not change the message, and ordered them to send it out as it was.

Upon the fleet's arrival at Titan, the Vanguard and refugees landed at the New Pacific Arcology to set up base and plan their counterattack, however they found that the Hive had established a stronghold there. Under Zavala's command, Sloane sent two teams to scout the Arcology to determine the extent of the Hive's infestation. Both teams were wiped out in the mission, but reported back enough information to confirm nearly the entire Arcology was under Hive control. Sloane reported the situation to Zavala, but believed even without the Light that the Guardians could storm the Arcology and wipe out the Hive, stating that if they needed they could burn down the entire place to drive them out. Her commander did not even turn to look at her, merely lamenting that he had been a fool to come to Titan and that their strength could not match the Hive. Increasingly concerned about Zavala's demeanor, Sloane told him he was not wrong and that Titan had all the resources and technology they needed to strike back at the Cabal if they could defeat the Hive, but Zavala cut her off and ordered all forces pulled back to the landing area they secured before dismissing her.

Zavala sharing his plans to Sloane and the Guardian.

Eventually, the Iron Lord known as the Young Wolf arrived, claiming to have regained their Light. Despite Zavala's worry, Sloane asked the Young Wolf to help them secure the facility and prepare their forces by capturing the control center in Siren's Watch. With their Light, the Young Wolf easily cut through the Hive and reached the control center. Sloane's hopes were raised by the Guardian's success, and she told Zavala that they would be able to start planning their offensive soon, but the Commander was unconvinced it would be so easy. Sloane directed the Young Wolf to clear out the Hive's breeding grounds, and they eliminated Ubara, Hive Prince to secure the area. Sloane and Zavala landed at the control center to greet the Guardian, and she gave them a grateful nod as she entered the control room to set up the Guardian's temporary headquarters.

With a command center established, Sloane and the others turned their attention to restoring power to the station. She and Amanda informed the Young Wolf that they would guide them over the comms to the pistons that needed to be restarted. As they progressed, Sloane informed them that the Fallen on Titan had followed them from Earth, and noted that they needed to get Amanda flying again so she could provide support on these missions. When the pilot reminded her that her Hawk had been heavily damaged, Sloane informed her she would have it moved to the top of the repair queue. When the Guardian reached the pistons, they learned some of them had been encased in Hive chitin, which Sloane directed to be destroyed so the pistons could function properly. When all the pistons were clear but power still did not return, Sloane suggested the Young Wolf make their way to the central power platform and flip the central circuit breaker, hoping that would be sufficient to restore power. Her solution worked, and while the others celebrated having power, Sloane told her team they had done good work but they still needed to decode the intercepted transmissions.

Sloane attempts to caution Zavala's plans to assault The Almighty.

When the Guardian returned to the command center in Siren's Watch, Sloane took a brief moment to admire the view and thanked them for helping get the command center powered. She then revealed that she was ready to begin plotting the Vanguard's counterattack against the Red Legion and needed their help to do it. The first step was to decode the transmissions they had intercepted using an advanced CPU that Amanda had detected deeper into the Arcology complex. Sloane warned the Young Wolf that they had no intel on the Hive presence within and was worried that they could be summoning anything in their warrens. Despite the heavy Hive presence, the Young Wolf succeeded in their mission and Sloane used the CPU to decrypt the transmissions. To her horror, she learned the Red Legion had positioned a superweapon known as The Almighty in orbit of the sun and would use it to destroy the entire solar system once they had what they wanted, and that they had done so to hundreds of other systems they conquered. Sloane briefed Zavala and the Young Wolf on the situation, and defeatedly noted that the war was already essentially lost. Zavala refused to believe that and decided that they would launch an all-out assault on The Almighty and questioned when the fleet would be ready to attack. Sloane tried to caution him, but he cut her off, noting that if they waited they would all die and that their only hope was to fight and reclaim the Last City and their Light, ending with a declaration that he needed the rest of his fireteam, Cayde-6 and Ikora Rey.

Retaking Earth

"Sorry I couldn't be there when you finally took the fight to Ghaul. We did our share of damage in the streets, though. I've never been so happy to get some new dents in my armor. Looks like you've got some new ones too. Turning the tide of a war will do that."

— Sloane to the Young Wolf after the liberation of the Last City

After Cayde and Ikora joined Zavala, the Young Wolf, and the rest of the resistance at The Farm on Earth, Sloane continued to provide tactical support and plan operations from her outpost on Titan. She contacted the Young Wolf upon learning that the Red Legion was moving high-yield explosives in the Sunken Isles near Firebase Hades in the European Dead Zone. Sloane directed for them to be destroyed, although Suraya Hawthorne protested that they could be used against the Cabal. A intercepted manifest pointed to the location of the remaining explosives within the firebase, and Sloane wanted them transmatted away. Hawthorne suggested using transmat juice to detonate them, which Sloane incredulously repeated, but Hawthorne shot back that she probably did not know how transmats worked either. Realizing that she did not, Sloane quickly declared that the topic was not relevant and ordered the Young Wolf into the base, where they placed transmat beacons on three explosive devices. Sloane detected several heavy tanks offline near the Young Wolf's position and ordered them to leave before they were activated, but Hawthorne interrupted and told them to go outside to the tanks. Sloane was skeptical of what she was planning, but her skepticism turned to admiration when Hawthorne told them to retransmat the explosives to the tanks. She had the Young Wolf guard the explosives from a Cabal counterattack while their Ghost prepared them for detonation and told Hawthorne that this was a good plan. Once the explosives were detonated and the tanks destroyed, Sloane requested the Young Wolf withdraw before more Cabal arrived. After they escaped the base, Sloane congratulated everyone on their successful mission and declared she would track down the explosives that had been sent away, while Hawthorne declared they made a good team and should work together again in the future.

When the final assault began on the Last City to reclaim it from the Red Legion, Sloane returned to Earth and fought in the streets of the occupied City. She eagerly took the battle to the invaders and received new damage to her armor, but survived the battle long enough for the Young Wolf to defeat Dominus Ghaul and for the Traveler to awaken and destroy the cage trapping the Light, restoring its gifts to Sloane and the other Guardians. In the aftermath of the battle, Sloane was ordered by Zavala to return to Titan and secure the moon and Saturn against any threats that presented themselves in the region. When the Young Wolf stopped by Titan, Sloane apologized for not assisting them in person during the reclamation of the Last City. She noted that it would be wise for the Red Legion to retreat now that they had suffered so many defeats and declared that if they were too stubborn to do so the Guardians would continue pushing them back.

Securing Titan

Race against the Fallen

When Commander Zavala and Sloane fled to Titan to establish a secret base against the Red Legion, the Fallen saw an opportunity to follow them there like Vultures as Sloane describes them. The Fallen quickly got to work after finding long abandoned Golden Age cities such as the New Pacific Arcology ripe for plunder and intercepted many unmanned shipments sent to Earth by Sloane.

Later a group of Fallen led by Mithrax, the Forsaken competed against the Guardians sent by Sloane to gain access to an ancient methane reactor, with the motivation of boosting Ether production for Servitors by doubling or tripling the output.

Mithrax would always be one step ahead of the Guardians by constructing various barriers along the way to halt the Guardians progress. Finally Mithrax is seen duelling against Golthor, the Subtle in which Guardians are given a choice in who to kill. By killing the Hive Knight and sparing Mithrax will trigger an ending in which he'll thank the Guardians with an Eliksni display of respect to the surprise of Sloane and Zavala. He disappears and grants the player access to the reactor, putting question to an Fallen and Human alliance.

Savathûn's Song

After the Vanguard discovered evidence of a Hive ritual being conducted in the warrens beneath the New Pacific Arcology, Sloane prepared a team of nine Guardians to enter the warrens and disrupt the ritual. She briefed one of the fireteams, which was led by the Praxic Warlock Taeko-3, and found herself frustrated by their cockiness and underestimation of the Hive. After Taeko claimed that the three of them were unstoppable, she questioned what would happen if Taeko found herself alone without backup against the Hive. The Exo merely smirked and claimed she would embrace the Praxic Fire.

This proved to be foolhardy as her fireteam quickly became trapped by the Hive within the Archeology and hunted down, killed, and converted into crystals full of Void Light for use in a summoning ritual. Taeko as the lone survivor watched as her best friends were desecrated by the Hive and made contact with the rescue team sent by Commander Zavala and Sloane. She soon discovered a huge Shrieker known as Savathûn's Song was responsible for the horrors the Hive were committing and dissuaded the rescue team from coming any further. Taeko's sacrifice was not in vain, as the strike team was able to destroy the monstrous Shrieker and prevent whatever ritual the Hive were preparing for from occurring.

Outpost Commander

Sloane by her outpost

This section needs expansion. You can help Destinypedia by expanding it.

"Zavala wasn't thrilled about you running off after Cayde's killers. Can't say I blame him… Just tell me you got 'em. What? Even I know duty and obligation don't always line up."

— Sloane, to the Young Wolf following Cayde's death

Several months after the conclusion of the Red War, Sloane remained on Titan as the commander of the Vanguard's New Pacific Arcology outpost. She received word of Cayde-6's death in the Reef at the hands of Uldren Sov and the Scorn Barons while attempting to stop a riot in the Prison of Elders, and that the Young Wolf had defied Zavala to seek revenge on the murderers. The next time they visited Titan, Sloane stated that she understood why the Commander was upset, but wanted to know if Cayde had been avenged. Noting the Young Wolf's surprise, Sloane revealed that she understood that duty could not always be put before their personal obligations to their friends and that she admired the Young Wolf for seeking justice. She told them that she supported them and wished them luck in keeping up their good work.

The Arrival

The Pyramid above Titan's methane ocean.

"When it all started, me, Zavala, Shaxx… we didn't build the wall; we were the wall. I told Zavala once: I was there for the beginning, and I'll be there for the end. It's not the end yet."

— Sloane, deciding to stay on Titan and fight the Darkness

Shortly after routine shipment of Golden Age technology back to the Last City from the Arcology, a Fallen Ketch arrived at Siren's Watch to let off a landing party of Dregs to steal from Sloane's work crews. Sloane intervened and the attackers were repelled, but contrary to her expectations, the Fallen had been after supplies rather than the Golden Age technology that took off not long before, leading her to the conclusion that the Fallen were leaving the Arcology. It wouldn't take long to find out why, as she looked up into the sky and saw a Pyramid hovering inside Titan's atmosphere.

Sloane was visited by the Young Wolf under orders of Zavala to determine what her plans were for combating the threat. She was pleased to see her old friend, and noted that while Zavala was focused on the Pyramids she was concerned about what the Hive were up to. Sloane informed the Young Wolf that the Hive were taking advantage of the Pyramids arrival distracting the Vanguard to dig deeper into the Golden Age secrets of the Arcology. She declared that she would not allow them to pick the bones of humanity before they were even dead and issued orders to the Young Wolf to disrupt the Hive's operations. When they reported back after disrupting the Hive operations, Sloane thanked them and stated she would put together a plan to deal with them and the Pyramid. She then fell silent as she looked over the methane seas of Titan, now darkened by the Pyramid, and exchanged nods of respect with the Young Wolf as they departed.

Due to the Pyramids presence, many of Sloane's work crews were evacuated from Titan, leaving the platforms to the mercy of the methane ocean's waves and Sloane in a foul mood due to the constant shaking. She contacted Amanda in the hopes her friend could guide her through constructing something to stabilize the platform and allow her to focus on overseeing operations. However, most of Amanda's suggestions were beyond Sloane's capability, and she had no time to search the Arcologies to locate an Engram that might contain a useful wavebreaking structure. After hearing the last of Amanda's ideas and watching her spill her ramen attempting to mime them, Sloane gave her a cheery wave as she signed off. However, she stayed in alone in her darkened office for some time afterwards, reflecting on the situation.

Zavala soon ordered a full evacuation of Titan and other locations throughout the solar system which had been occupied by the Pyramids. Sloane oversaw the evacuation of all personnel and supplies from the moon, but remained concerned about the Hive's activity. She learned that Pryn-rid, Treasurer of Savathûn was leading a team of Hive in locating specific pieces of Golden Age tech, but did not interfere in order to let them find it and then take it from them. When the Young Wolf returned, Sloane informed them that she had learned of a important Hive ritual being conducted in the Arcology ruins and of her plan to seize the tech from Pryn-rid. A report had recently arrived confirming the Hive had recovered the tech and Sloane ordered the Young Wolf to recover it. When her friend returned with the tech, Sloane revealed that she had been researching it and learned it was a suit of survival gear and claimed it for her own. She told them that she intended to remain on Titan and face whatever emerged from the Pyramids head on, with her resolute determination halting the Young Wolf from protesting. Sloane softly recalled how she and her fellow Titans like Zavala and Shaxx were once the wall keeping the Last City safe, and resolved to be the wall on Titan. Giving a small smile to the Guardian, she stated that she had told Zavala that she would be there for the end and that she was determined to ensure that this would not be the end yet. She was confident that Zavala, of all people, would understand her decision to stay and fight.

After watching the Young Wolf depart Titan for the final time, Sloane entered her office and put on the recovered suit of power armor. Upon putting on the helmet she realized the controls were not in a language she knew, but guessed the correct option to select to active the armor. As it conformed to her size, Sloane tested her movement and tried to summon Arc energy, but the suit blocked it. She decided she would need to learn how to utilize her Light through the suit and adjusted more settings before moving outside, finding that each step and move she made synched the suit more to her and made it easier to control. As a massive storm hit Siren's Watch, a Thrall charged her, but Sloane easily grabbed it by the head and ripped it apart with the enhanced strength of the armor. Her laugh was broadcast by the suit as a battle cry that echoed throughout the abandoned platform and up the overhead Pyramid as the storm raged around her.

Sloane's current status is unknown. However, following the disappearance of Titan, both she and Asher Mir were declared MIA.

Personality and Traits

Deputy Commander Sloane

Much like Zavala, Sloane is regarded as a stern Titan commander. Zavala thought of her as not only a friend, but a strong tactician and right-hand as his Deputy-Commander. However, she was more morally flexible than her friend and supported the Young Wolf's campaign against the Scorn to avenge Cayde-6's murder, believing that duty should not always come first in a Guardian's life, especially after losing a comrade.

Quotes

Cayde's Death Quote

• Zavala wasn't thrilled about you running off after Cayde's killers. Can't say I blame him… Just tell me you got 'em. What? Even I know duty and obligation don't always line up. That's why I like you, Guardian. You don't just deal in justice, you embody it. Keep up the good fight. I'm rooting for you.

Story Mission: Utopia Quotes

• Ahh. It's a hell of a view, isn't it? We're up and running thanks to you. There's plenty more to do around here, though. Chief among them — finally breaking ground on a counteroffensive against the Red Legion. I have a plan, but it won't work without you. We intercepted a priority one Red Legion signal during the City evacuation, but we can't crack the encryption. Holliday says there's tech that can do the job in the Arcology, which is effectively hostile territory. You'd be going in blind. The place has been dark for centuries. All we know for sure is the Hive is raising hell down there, perhaps literally. But if you're in... Let's put the plan into action.
• They call it... "The Almighty." The crown jewel of the Red Legion and life's work of their leader... Dominus Ghaul. Ghaul has subjugated hundreds of worlds. Those that resisted… no longer exist. You see, The Almighty… annihilates stars. Nothing- and no one- survives Ghaul's ambition. What he wants… is the Traveler. And its Light. As for The Almighty... it's now pointed at our sun. In short, sir... the war's over. And we've lost.
• Zavala, wait-

Story Mission: Riptide Quotes

• All right, we're not out of this yet. Now that we've reached the Control Center, we still need to power up this place before we can take care of our Fleet. Commander Zavala tells me you've volunteered. I'll run tactical. Shipwright Holliday here will provide tech support. It's a straightforward op: get in, flip a switch, get out.
• No. Those vultures have been following us since we evacuated Earth.
• Holliday, we gotta get you back in the air. We'll need ongoing aerial threat assessments to keep our perimeter secure.
• I'll bump you to the front of the line for repairs once the lights are back on.
• Then let's find a fix.
• Sounds like you got more scrubbing to do, Guardian.
• Try the Central Platform. Everything routes through there.
• Circuit breaker's going to be around there somewhere. Find it and flip the switch. Just like I said.
• Exemplary work, everyone. But we still have to deal with these intercepted enemy transmissions.

Story Mission: Hope Quotes

• Commander, if I may. Guardian, this is Deputy Commander Sloane. We have a counter-offensive to plan. To do that, we need to get this station up and running. There's a fleet to prep, Guardians to arm, and a trove of intercepted Red Legion transmissions to decrypt. It's critical we gain access to the station's Control Center. That's where you come in. If the Light really is with you, send the Hive back to hell.
• Copy that. Keep pushing forward. Commander. At this rate, we can start planning our counteroffensive. We'll be outside the City gates in no time.
• Clear the area so we can move in.
• Perfect. Recon the perimeter before you move on the Control Center.
• Well done. Sweep the perimeter, and we'll move in on your signal.
• Copy that. Zavala and I are inbound. We're approaching the landing platform. Get up here, and take a bow.

Adventure: Thief of Thieves Quotes

• They hit us and ran. We lost tools, gear… My crews can't work without that stuff.
• My crews will be reinforcing this Rig again in no time.
• Give those thieves a taste of their own medicine.
• Good job. I'll set up a transmat. Wait… Wait a minute. Where's my beacon?
• You've cleaned them out. These components are critical to the Rig's structural integrity. And thanks to you, we've got the tools to put them back.

Adventure: Bad Neighbors Quotes

• My crew says we've got two problems. Wizards on a tower roof, doing who knows what, and the Fallen they've spooked.
• Fallen first. They're using fuel cells to build an explosive countermeasure to the Hive. Sloppy stuff. It'll blow us all sky high.
• Good. Sending you coordinates to the Hive.
• What should work?
• Up. You're looking for the top of a tower, the central platform.
• Eliminate the Wizards, destroy their project, and stabilize this Rig.
• How bad's the damage?
• (Sigh) I'll take your word for it.

Adventure: Siren Song Quotes

• Guardian, we're reading some odd fluctuations in our scans.
• I've got three locations where the waves are strongest. Sending you coordinates.
• What are you picking up?
• Get over there, and we should be able to track those gravity waves back to their source.
• Oh, I hear it. Amanda's grabbed your data and is mapping the source now.
• Then let's do the same to them.
• The sooner the better. We're hearing that sound on all sensors now. Feeling it, too.
• I feel… sick.
• Neutralize it!
• We're stable again. Whatever you did, it worked. My… stomach thanks you.
• I'm sure I'm going to hear all about what Amanda will use that for. What were the Hive doing with it?

Adventure: Deathless Quotes

• Good, it's you. I'm getting reports from Holliday's crews about a Knight with a strange aura around it. It's playing merry hell with our schedule.
• Sure. But this rig isn't winning any races. That Knight is in my way. Take it out.
• New Hive spells. Just what we need. Get after it you two.
• I'm not in the mood for this. Keep after him. Their spell can't keep that thing safe forever.
• I've been fighting Hive for — well — longer than I want to admit. This is some kind of ritual.
• Maybe. What's their goal, though? Why let this thing die over and over again?
• If this is a ritual, then all of this is leading somewhere. I want the two of you there at the end, whatever that looks like.
• Good work, both of you. You know, Holliday and I were just talking about how different we are from the Hive.
• Oh, no. Amanda goes rogue and we'll have Thrall buzzing the control center inside a week. Ahem. But, uh, let's get back to work.

Adventure: No Safe Distance Quotes

• Good, someone I can count on. The Cabal are moving high-yield explosives through that base. You need to neutralize them before they're used against us.
• "Transmat juice?"
• That's not relevant. Get into that base, and find those explosives.
• There are heavy tanks near your position. Get out of there before they come online.
• The tanks are outside.
• Hawthorne, that is some good improvisation.
• Hold that position. Those tanks are too important a target to leave standing.
• No argument here.
• A well-timed tactical withdrawal is probably wise.
• We'll try to track down the explosives that got away. In the meantime, great work. Those tanks would have been a lot to handle.

Gameplay

Sloane serves as the Overseer of Titan and its main questgiver. She is situated in Siren's Watch. Turning in Arcology tokens, Alkane Dust and Alkane Spores increases player reputation with Sloane and rewards legendary faction gear, shaders and other rewards. The weapons in her inventory are mostly from Suros.

Armor

• Lost Pacific Armor

Faction Weapons

• Solemn Hymn
• Tone Patrol
• Annual Skate
• Dead Man Walking
• Foggy Notion
• A Single Clap
• Swift Ride
• Negative Space
• Nox Echo III
• Hoosegow

Trivia

• Sloane is voiced by Cissy Jones.
• Sloane's left pauldron bears several seals reminiscent of Warhammer 40000 Purity Seals given to noteworthy Space Marines who have proven themselves faithful and untainted by Chaos.
• Sloane is seen on Titan with her face and arms exposed; given that Titan has apparently not been terraformed by the Traveler, and that methane becomes liquid at -161.49 degrees Celsius (-258.68 degrees Fahrenheit), it is unknown how she can survive without protective equipment.

Gallery

• 

  Sloane is seen on the right, helping Lord Shaxx with the construction of the walls around The Last City.

List of appearances

• Destiny: Warmind (comic)
• Destiny: Age of Triumph (First mentioned)
• Destiny 2 (First appearance)
  • Curse of Osiris (Mentioned only)
  • Warmind (Mentioned only)
    • Solstice of Heroes
  • Forsaken
    • Black Armory
  • Season of Dawn (Mentioned only)
  • Season of the Worthy (Mentioned only)
  • Season of Arrivals
  • Beyond Light (Mentioned only)